Phenomenal Awareness

Phenomenal Awareness

Attention Exercises

When Nothing Comes to Mind

Watch the mind’s eye to notice when it rests.

Daron Larson's avatar
Daron Larson
Nov 22, 2026
∙ Paid

This is the fifth installment of Find Rest in the Unrest, a ten-part series exploring how to notice and savor restful sensations amid ordinary life. Explore the series.


Watching the visual side of thinking sounds abstract, but in the multi-sensory mindfulness approach I practice and teach, it’s surprisingly tangible.

A couple of weeks ago, we explored the difference between looking closely at what is right in front of us and having our eyes open without really paying attention to what we are seeing. We can become so absorbed in our thoughts that the visual world fades into the background—even though so much of it is right in front of us.

This series isn’t about finding hacks to force ourselves to relax when we’re agitated. It’s about becoming connoisseurs of restful sensations—learning to recognize the relatively inactive side of ordinary sensory experience and discovering what happens when we give it some attention.

This week, we’re turning toward the visual side of thinking.

The movies in our minds

One obstacle to observing mental imagery is that movies and TV shows have given us misleading expectations about what it should look like.

When a character in a film remembers something from childhood, we typically see a fully realized scene. There might be a change in lighting, a younger actor, or a wavy transition to signal that we’ve moved into the past. But once we arrive, the memory is just as visually detailed as the action taking place in the present.

It’s easy to assume that picturing something in our own minds should work the same way.

But what happens when we investigate this in the laboratory of our own minds?

Mental imagery exists along a continuum. Sometimes a mental picture is vivid. Sometimes it’s recognizable but fuzzy. Sometimes it’s barely detectable. And sometimes we can think about a person, place, or event without finding anything particularly visual in our perceptions at all.

People vary considerably on this one. I’ve worked with artists and architects who describe remarkably vivid mental imagery. I know people who can study a map and later picture it in considerable detail.

My own experience tends toward the other end of the spectrum. Most of my mental images are surprisingly faint, which I’ve found useful at times.

Following the breadcrumbs

When I was training for my first marathon, long before podcasts and smartphones offered endless distraction, I came up with a little game to entertain myself during long runs.

I’d notice whatever happened to be on my mind and try to work backward.

What was I thinking just before this? And what was I thinking before that?

I was fascinated by how seemingly unrelated subjects were connected through nearly imperceptible associations.

A thought about work might lead to a particular coworker, which reminded me of a previous job, which brought to mind a former boss, which somehow led to an entirely different subject.

The connections weren’t necessarily random. But they happened so quickly that I rarely noticed them as they occurred.

Looking back, I suspect a complex cluster of barely perceptible, fleeting mental images helped connect the dots, often accompanied by an emotional undercurrent. I couldn't necessarily see the connections clearly, even when I could follow the chain of thoughts they seemed to produce.

Years later, as my mindfulness practice developed, I became increasingly interested in separating the sensory components of thinking rather than getting quite as absorbed in the stories they combined to tell.

I could listen to the words in my mind. I could feel the emotional sensations in my body. And I could investigate whatever pictures appeared in my mind’s eye.

What surprised me was how differently these components behaved when I paid attention to them.

A surprisingly accessible place to rest

When I’m worried or preoccupied, the verbal and emotional aspects of my experience can be remarkably active.

My mind is busy arguing, rehearsing conversations, imagining outcomes, or trying to solve problems that can’t be solved right now. Meanwhile, my body contributes its own sensations of urgency, tension, or dread.

It’s a compelling production. The dialogue is loud and biting. The emotional soundtrack is sweeping and dramatic.

But when I look for the visual side of all this activity, the mental pictures are often surprisingly faint.

It’s as though the mind has assembled an elaborate movie without bothering to render much of the visual detail.

This is one of the discoveries at the heart of this series: restfulness doesn’t necessarily arrive when unrest subsides. Relatively restful sensations can coexist with intensely active ones.

The verbal thinking can be loud. The emotional sensations can be uncomfortable. And the visual side of thinking can be almost imperceptible.

All at the same time.

I don’t have to make the words stop, or the feelings disappear, to notice that one part of the experience is already relatively restful.

And here’s what I’ve found useful about that.

I have a strong, instinctive habit of resisting uncomfortable feelings. I can also find myself wishing that the verbal thinking would quiet down. I've come to see these habits not as personal flaws, but as familiar features of being human.

But faint mental imagery doesn’t provoke the same impulse to automatically interfere as mental talk and emotional body sensations do.

When I notice how fuzzy or fleeting the pictures already are, I often feel less compelled to do anything about them.

I can let them be faint.

Sometimes they become even fainter. At other times they get a little clearer before fading.

And sometimes, resting my attention on that relatively inactive part of an otherwise restless experience begins to change my relationship with the rest of it.

The words may continue. The uncomfortable feelings may still be there. But I don’t have to engage with every component of the experience at once or try to stop the entire production.

Sometimes this creates a little less resistance, which can take some of the momentum out of the emotional storyline.

Not always. And not necessarily immediately.

But often enough to make it a skill worth developing.

Seeing what’s already there

We experience a related phenomenon when we’re absorbed in thought during a familiar commute.

We may arrive at our destination with surprisingly little recollection of the scenery along the way. Our attention has been occupied by an internal conversation, a memory, or a rehearsal of something that hasn’t happened yet.

None of that internal activity needs to resemble a vivid movie to compete for our attention.

Conversely, becoming more curious about what we’re actually seeing can sometimes make the internal production less absorbing. When driving, noticing the changing colors, shapes, and details of the road ahead can help keep attention where it belongs.

Today’s attention exercise begins by deliberately calling a few people, places, and objects to mind. Then we’ll stop trying to picture anything and observe what happens spontaneously.

Are the images vivid? Fuzzy? Faint? Is there anything visual to detect at all?

We’re not trying to make the mental screen go blank. We’re learning to distinguish between the meaning of an image and the sensory experience of picturing it.

A mental image doesn’t have to be vivid to influence what we’re thinking and feeling. And it doesn’t have to disappear for us to discover something restful about it.

The more familiar we become with these relatively inactive sensations, the more opportunities we may discover to notice and savor them in ordinary life—even when other parts of our experience are anything but restful.


Please support my work—and get access to every guided exercise—for only $5 a month.


Exercise

This attention exercise explores the visual side of thinking. We'll deliberately call a few images to mind, then observe how vivid, fuzzy, faint, or absent mental pictures can be. Instead of trying to clear your mind, we'll practice noticing the restful side of visual thinking—even when thoughts and feelings are still active.

When to use this attention exercise:

  • When you’re replaying an uncomfortable conversation.

  • When you’re worrying about something that hasn’t happened.

  • When you wake up in the middle of the night with a busy mind.

  • When you're looking out a window or taking a walk.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Daron Larson.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Daron Larson · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.